Sunday, March 01, 2009

Tenochtitlán and Xochimilco: Mexico City before the Conquest

When the Spanish conquistadors got their first look at the Aztec city of Tenochtitlán in 1519, they compared its magnificence to Venice and Istanbul.

They were awestruck at the grand causeways that linked the city in the lake with the mainland. They marveled at the busy traffic of boats on the canals and the skyline traced by grand temples and palaces. Historians estimate that 200,000 to 400,000 people lived there, making it one of the largest cities on earth at that time.

Muralist Diego Rivera´s painting (above) in the National Palace captures what the city must have looked like. Here is a quote from one of Cortez´s party:

When we saw so many cities and villages built in the water and other great towns on dry land we were amazed and said that it was like the enchantments (...) on account of the great towers and cues and buildings rising from the water, and all built of masonry. And some of our soldiers even asked whether the things that we saw were not a dream? (...) I do not know how to describe it, seeing things as we did that had never been heard of or seen before, not even dreamed about.
— Bernal Díaz del Castillo

This was the city of Aztec emperor Moctezuma that Cortez wanted to hand over as a prize to his king, Emperor Charles V (above, a 1930 artistic impression). But in the terrible siege of 1521, Cortez and his army, supported by thousands of the Aztecs´ enemies, ended up destroying most of it.


The Spaniards built their cathedral on the ruins of the Great Temple in the heart of today´s Mexico City. The photo above shows part of the ruins, which were uncovered in the 1970s.

British historian Hugh Thomas has written one of the best histories of this monumental clash of civilizations, Conquest: Cortes, Montezuma and the Fall of Old Mexico.

Xochimilco, more than 100 miles of canals



Just south of Mexico City lies Xochimilco, where you can see some of the last vestiges of the canals that impressed the Spanish conquistadors.



Hundreds or maybe thousands of tourist boats ply the canals. All are poled manually to prevent erosion of the banks. Each boat has a table and chairs in the center for large parties to eat, drink and relax for a couple of hours.





All manner of sales take place. You have vendors of food, toys, drinks and entertainment. For about $5 a mariachi band on a boat will pull alongside and serenade you.

Along the banks are greenhouses and nurseries that produce vegetables and flowers for the metropolitan area of more than 20 million people.

Why newspaper exposés have little impact in México

Every day I read Mural and Público Milenio, two of the most important newspapers in Guadalajara, and I´m instantly depressed.

The amount of corruption, self-dealing, inefficiency and mismanagement in the public sector chronicled by these two newspapers is staggering. What´s depressing is that despite the publication of this information, almost nothing happens.

One newspaper editor here explained to me that the news media themselves are considered suspect by the public. Readers tend to assume that the owners of the newspaper or media outlet are using an exposé for political reasons, to punish enemies.

At the same time there are no ambitious procecutors or legislators ready to hold the villains accountable. The few citizens groups pressing for change are relatively ineffective.

A system with little accountability
People here don´t view the government and public money as theirs. They view it as the private playground of the politicians. Seventy years of rule by a single powerful party, the PRI, provided a kind of stability and the appearances of democracy but no real citizen involvement and no responsiveness. People don´t complain to their congressman or councilman. They don´t see the elected officials as their representatives. Voters are apathetic.

Long before drug money exacerbated the corruption, the political system was self-contained, self-sustaining. The courts, the public prosecutors, the labor unions, the police, the congress and the executive branch are all part of this system whose purpose is to share power, influence and money among themselves. The head of the teachers union, which gets enormous sums from the government, feels free to buy 59 Hummers for her local organizers, and there is an outcry, a bunch of lame excuses and then...nothing.

Nobody wants to rock the boat because their own private source of money and influence might be tossed overboard.

During the 2003 mid-term elections, after the PAN party had overthrown the PRI monopoly, this quote in the New York Times from a writer and painter, Enrique Canales, seemed emblematic:

''The control of the political bureaucracy, the teachers, the police, the bus drivers, that hasn't changed,'' he said. ''The PAN tries to clean up the system, but 85 percent of the people in it remain PRI-istas. So the changes that the PAN proposes do not show up at the local level. People don't see a difference. People don't see a change. It will take two decades to change things.''


Corruption indexes
Various indexes try to measure the corruption in Mexico -- Transparency International among them. By one estimate, corruption consumes 8-12% of Mexico´s GNP, but that doesn´t really capture the inertia of the system.


Failed state

The Pentagon has referred to Mexico as at risk of becoming a “failed state” because large areas of the country are controlled by druglords who own the politicans, from governors to state legislators to police chiefs and, in some cases, journalists. Mexican President Felipe Calderón strongly denies this characterization.

Update March 24: A leading Mexican journalist writing in the New York Times says talk of Mexico as a failed state is a wild exaggeration not based on the facts.


However the leader of a Mexican citizens group pointed out that organized crime has its own system of charging taxes (protection) in many parts of the country.

The Wall Street Journal had an in-depth piece recently on the growing power of the drug cartels in Mexico.

Monday, February 23, 2009

My calvario, or the 10 steps needed to join a public pool

In the Latin world, an arduous process is called un calvario, which means it´s like the stages of Christ´s progress from arrest to torture to crucifixion.

In the end, he rose from the dead. And I eventually got my pool pass. This is the story of my calvario.

People in Latin countries admire the efficiency of the Germans and Americans and try to imitate them by setting up all kinds of rules meant to establish order. I wish that they imitated the way Americans and Germans run pools.

Olympic pools are simpler
In order to swim in the Olympic pool in Munich where Mark Spitz won 7 gold medals, I simply entered, paid a small fee and jumped in. In order to become a year-long member of the pool in Baltimore where Michael Phelps trained to win his 8 Olympic golds, I signed a form, paid a modest fee, had a photo ID produced on the spot and could swim any time, any day from 6 a.m. till 10 at night. Even when Michael was there.

Medical exam required
It´s not so simple here at the public park near our apartment. First you need a medical examination to prove you won´t die in the pool and that you´re not covered with infectious scabs.

And you can´t get the exam from any of the evidently untrustworthy private physicians or private hospitals, which might be subject to undue influence by their clients. You have to go to a Red Cross or Green Cross facility, staffed by efficient, incorruptible public servants.

There you pay about $25 for an intern to ask you whether you have any skin diseases (of course not) or heart condition or diabetes. Four copies of the form are produced and stamped authoritatively with resounding thumps.

Only certain days in one specific hour

Then I take the exam to the pool´s cashier, who first claims that my exam is invalid because I had used a private hospital. I argue my case with a brashness I´m ashamed to use in English, and I win.

Then I learn that I have to pick the days I will swim under this pool membership (it´s a state-owned pool, remember, not private). Either M-W-F or Tu-Th. Swimming all 5 days costs more than the two plans combined, illogically. And I have to choose a specific hour to swim. So for the year that I am a member, I can only swim from 6 to 7 p.m. I can never show up at 9 or 10, never at 4 or 5. Only that chosen time slot.

So I opt for the M-W-F, 6-7 p.m, for $22 a month plus a one-time initiation fee of $12 and another $3 for a photo ID. (I had to come back a second time because you have to produce the photos yourself).

Insurance against something

Oh, and I have to buy accident insurance for another $10. I wonder what it´s like to try to make a claim on it, and I wonder which crony´s company has this contract.

The first day I try to use the pass, the gatekeeper tells me that it´s no good on Wednesdays. Turns out they mistakenly stamped my pass for Tues-Thurs. I make another trip to the cashier´s office on the opposite side of the park. My pass is authoritatively stamped again.

At the pool, I am told that I must show I can swim 25 meters each of crawl, breaststroke and backstroke. I pass and am now approved. Oh, and I have to wear a cap.

No rules on the weekend
The wonder of all these regulations is that on Saturdays and Sundays, anyone can use the pool by paying $2.75. No medical exam is required, no photo ID required, no cap, no proof of backstroke and no stinking insurance required.

This all makes sense to someone. But I´m just a stranger here in these parts.

Thursday, February 05, 2009

Genetic map of Mexico shows mainly indigenous roots

Race can be a touchy subject in Mexico. Some are proud of their indigenous blood, others not so much.

A genetic-molecular study of the Mexican population shows the European component is highest in northern states -- from 38% to 50% -- and lowest in the southeast -- from 9% to 20%.

It was already well known that about 80% of the population of Mexico is mestizo, of mixed race. The mainly male Spanish conquistadores intermarried with indigenous women and enslaved the native population to work in mines and on vast estates, haciendas.

By contrast, the immmigrants who colonized Canada and the U.S. brought their wives and families, and they exterminated or displaced the Indian population to reservations. There was far less intermarriage.

Hector Rangel Villalobos, director of the Institute of Molecular Genetics at the University of Guadalajara, did the study with six other researchers in Mexico and Spain. It provides a quantifiable molecular map of what historians and sociologists have observed using their own techniques.

A summary is in the Feb. 2 edition of La Gaceta on Page 2 of the O2 section.

Census shows native languages surviving
The Mexican census of 2005 shows that 6.7% of the population speaks an indigenous language as their mother tongue.

Sunday, February 01, 2009

Azaleas bloom in Guadalajara in January


In a nearby public park here in Guadalajara, el Bosque los Colomos, the azaleas are blooming in January.

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

A jazz musician needs to have 'damage'

Young Patrick Breiner, son of these bloggers, has some strong opinions about making a career in jazz. The joke is, What do you call a jazz musician without a girlfriend? Homeless.

[My friend] Ben grew up in Riverdale, NY. It’s actually quite a nice neighborhood. But he spent his high school years having a hell of a lot of fun and taking advantage of the fact that New York City was just a subway ride away. He’s been mugged several times. Sucker-punched several times (once, ironically, in Osh-Kosh). And he’s spent the last 8 years or thereabouts living on the cheap in Brooklyn and booking cross-country tours with incredibly noisy bands that are definitely going to lose money. So there’s definitely some damage in this guy’s life.


A conversation with a local musician that really sticks out in my mind occurred between set breaks at one of the first Madison gigs I had gone to hear. I was unimpressed with this particular band. Not that I go to hear music with the intention of being impressed, but I couldn’t enjoy this band. It reminded me of a group I had led when I was in high school. It made sense that the band I fronted when I was 17 had no groove and read out of fakebooks. We were 17. But these guys seemed to consider themselves professionals.


You can read his thoughts on the subject at the blog Madison Jazz.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Half of Mexicans in poll think Obama won´t help them

Although people in Mexico seem to be thrilled that Obama is president, they remain their skeptical selves.

According to a poll by La Jornada, one of Mexico´s leading newspapers, 51% believe he won´t be good for Mexico, 25% say he will and 24% don´t know.

The poll was taken by sending emails to 5,000 people all over Mexico; 69 percent of those replied, and 200 added written responses.

Mexicans generally are skeptical that anything good can happen to them, and they say, sure, Obama might be great but he has to deal with our politicians who are corrupt and inefficient. They don´t believe in systems and governments; they believe in personal relationships and individual people.

“Our people shouldn´t have hope in Obama, what we should have is efficient politicians and a capable president.” -- Salvador Fernando Flores, Guadalajara

“That Obama is an intelligent and able man, there´s no doubt. But it´s important to remember that the gringos don´t have friends, they have interests. If it suits them to treat us well, we´ll be OK.“ -- Ismael Iñiguez Romero, Guadalajara